Your Customers Don’t Compare You to Amazon. They Never Did.

WorkAI.TV Editorial Desk
4 Min Read

Share with your CMO

The “liquid expectations” doctrine, the widely circulated claim that customers benchmark every brand against the best experience they’ve had anywhere, including Amazon and Netflix, is marketing folklore dressed up as insight. Writing for CMSWire, analyst and CX critic Alan Pennington dismantles the premise using Category Entry Points and the Duplication of Purchase law, two pillars of established marketing science. The argument is that memory structures activate inside a single category at a time, so a frictionless Netflix checkout does nothing to reshape what a customer expects from their insurer, law firm, or retirement community.

What this means for your business

CMOs sitting on expensive cross-industry “experience benchmarking” programs should feel the floor shift under them. If your CX strategy is built on the assumption that Apple Store expectations now govern your B2B procurement portal or your hospital billing flow, you have been allocating budget and design effort against a threat that the data says doesn’t exist. The organizations most exposed are those that hired consultants to close a “gap” defined by comparing themselves to companies operating in entirely different cognitive territory.

Pennington’s argument holds, and it holds harder than the piece lets on. Category Entry Points, the specific situational triggers that move a consumer into buying mode for a particular category, are not a fringe theory. They come from a century of brand effects research, most rigorously codified by the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute. When someone needs fast food, their brain pulls fast-food memory structures, not an aggregated composite of every pleasant commercial experience they’ve ever had. Mental compartmentalization is the mechanism, and it’s not controversial in academic marketing circles, only in the LinkedIn content ecosystem where vendor-adjacent commentators, writing to sell survey software or CX platforms, need a universal bogeyman to sell against.

The practical damage from the liquid expectations myth is subtler than wasted budget. It trains CX teams to compete against a phantom, which means they stop doing the harder, more productive work of understanding what actually drives preference and repeat purchase inside their own category. The leading indicator that your team has fallen for the myth is a strategy deck full of Amazon and Ritz-Carlton references with no corresponding analysis of your actual category competitors. That deck is a signal, not of ambition, but of a strategy built on borrowed anxiety rather than your own customer data.

Concept deep-dive: Category Entry Points

A Category Entry Point is the specific need, situation, or emotion that triggers buying behavior in one market category and no other. Think of it as the mental doorway that opens only to a single room. When someone thinks “I need this done fast and don’t want to think about it,” their brain retrieves options inside the relevant category, not a cross-industry shortlist. For CMOs, this matters because brand memory structures must be built to appear at the right doorway, not to compete with every door in the building.

Based on reporting from Your Customers Don’t Compare You to Amazon. They Never Did., originally published 2026-11-18 14:18:00.

TAGGED:
Share This Article